The College Football Playoff Committee was supposed to clean up most of the problems that haunted the Bowl Championship Series for 17 years. By having a playoff, even just a four-team playoff, was supposed to give us the best teams in the country squaring off for the title on the field.
The committee has failed miserably and frankly it has little to do with whether Ohio State belongs in or not because we could place (Fill in the blank) in this spot and little would change. Let me lay out for you where the committee screwed this up.
1. With the addition of the Buckeyes, the College Football Playoff Committee (CFPC) essentially said that their decision could be determined by just one game. What other reason would they have chosen OSU over TCU or Baylor than based upon the Buckeyes’ 59-0 win over Wisconsin?
2. The committee took the easy way out with Ohio State thus avoiding the conflict over TCU getting ahead of Baylor. With every point the Buckeyes scored on Saturday night, a loud exhale was heard from the CFPC conference room.This was because they knew that they could choose OSU and despite wins on the final day, leave TCU and Baylor out in the cold.
3. Name recognition played a huge part. CFPC Chairman Jeff Long can tell us all day and all night that the name and power of the Ohio State brand had nothing to do with them being selected but I won’t believe him and I’m pretty sure the kids in Fort Worth and Waco feel the same.
They knew full-well that the first playoff needed as much star power as possible. With unbeaten and defending national champ Florida State in, Nick Saban’s dynasty-laden Tide in and Heisman winning Marcus Mariota and Oregon in it only made sense to have one more of college football’s upper echelon teams in the final four.
The Buckeyes travel as well as any team in college football. Baylor and TCU couldn’t have sold even a nugget of the tickets that Ohio State fans will purchase. Truth time; if TCU and Baylor were Oklahoma and Texas don’t you think one of them would have been chosen? The answer there is yes.
4. By selecting a team outside of the top four heading into the final rankings, the CFPC rendered their earlier rankings totally moot. There is absolutely no excuse for the CFPC not to have selected Baylor or TCU based upon this. They did exactly what they needed to do on Saturday and were punished because of OSU’s performance and ultimately strength of schedule.
No one can dispute the fact that Baylor had the least-difficult non-conference schedule in the country but my question then is this; why wasn’t that factored in previously?
This committee was political from the start and then proceeded to grandstand on the final day. The kids at Baylor and TCU were guilty of one thing this past weekend; they didn’t play for bigger name schools.
Florida State (+9) vs Oregon – The Rose Bowl will be filled with green as the Ducks’ faithful roll in. Often overlooked is the Oregon defense which will look forward ot the challenge of stopping Jameis Winston.
Ohio State (+10) vs Alabama – It’s a good thing the Buckeyes travel well because the Tide are playing in their backyard in the Superdome. This game will come down to who can control the trenches.